More

    Merkle Tree Proofs (MTP), Proof of Work Crypto Mining and ASIC Resistance Debate Heats Up

    Merkle Tree Proofs ASIC Resistance

    Egalitarian mining and the proof-of-work algorithm (PoW) makes ASIC resistance worth the pursuit. The algorithm, called Merkle Tree Proofs, is one that Zcoin seems to believe in and states that it is “premature” to give up this early on in the game.

    There are many reasons for ASIC resistance. The project is often quibbled about between algorithm and ASIC designers. With a MPT proof of work algorithm, mining centralization can be fought against, which arises from ASICs.

    Zcoin is looking to create a more level playing field and to do so, it is hoping to implement MPT. With such an implementation, it may be able to democratize, what it believes to be, an undemocratic cryptocurrency mining system. Here are three factors identified by ASIC and that it relates to ASIC resistant proof-of-work algorithms:

    • ASIC gains advantages over commodity hardware like CPU and GPUs, but such advantages are limited
    • The algorithm will become costlier to develop

    Accordingly, an ASIC resistant algorithm mitigates development of ASIC, which then allows individuals with commodity hardware like CPU and GPU to mine in an area that is more equal.

    There are two benefits to this approach, including more coin distribution and decentralized security. Rather than gathering security on the blockchain in large mining farms, the network’s security is dispersed evenly throughout and among miners. Some believe that decentralized hashrates may also enhance resistance to censorship.

    ASIC resistance also promotes distribution of more coins. MPT allows everyone to have a fair chance of earning a coin with their existing computer hardware, rather than needed to purchase specialized ASIC that mine specific algorithms. Some countries, such as Venezuela and Vietnam, have also banned ASIC import into their countries in an attempt to stagnate the development of cryptocurrencies.

    Some believe that ASICs should be welcomed, even when a coin is in its early stages of development. A condition to this adoption is that the ASIC must be commoditized, which means that it is widely available to the average consumer and manufacturers can compete to place ASICs at a competitive rate on the market.

    As one can tell, ASICs do have many benefits. For instance, the hashrates are stable and miners can enter their specific algorithm and need not switch from coin to coin during the mining process. Some also believe that this ultimately leads to more security on the network and higher levels of commodity hardware mining.

    Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Litecoin, and Dahs tend to do well with ASIC, perhaps because their communities have taken years to develop and they can be likened to new projects. Those who embrace ASIC at the early stage of a coin’s development may find themselves benefiting most. There is also discussion surrounding the creation of an open-source ASIC technology. This will enable manufacturers to produce them – but on the downside, larger companies with R&D will also need to produce ASICs that are more efficient so that they can be mined secretly on their coin distribution.

    There are some projects out there that are trying to control the process – one of the most notable being SIA, which has spend a lot of funds and time developing its own ASIC. Unfortunately, Bitmain seems to have beat SIA to it. SIA has now generated a hard fork in response in favor of its own miners, which works to defeat commoditization of ASICs. At the end of the day though, it is important to recognize that cryptocurrency projects are not part of the hardware business – and instead, they should be focusing on developing software and technology that provides companies with the tools and resources needed to develop ASICs.

    Those who are pushing for the commoditization of ASIC argue that there are a very select few of companies that are able to product ASICs – one such being the computer industry. Therein, companies such as Intel AMD and Nvidia are dominant players. The issue is that this argument bypasses the fact that dissimilar from companies where cryptocurrency mining is only a minuscule part of their business model, the main goal is to ensure that as many chips as possible are sold. As a result, there is little incentive for ASIC manufacturers to sell their ASIC if they will profit more by selling them through mining and at a price that leads to potential gains.

    Another group believes that ASIC resistance is impossible and that ASICs for any algorithm is just part of the game. While there is some truth that ASICs can be developed for any algorithm, it is possible to increase the cost of development and manufacturing, which will then reduce potential gains in efficiency. This may then lead to the delay of ASICs development.

    This is already apparent when it comes to SHA 256 ASICs, which are attributed to Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash. These ASICs are faster than GPU. Further, Scrypt ASICs for Litecoin and Dogecoin are also fast, and algorithms like Equihash, which is used in Zcash, are five to ten times faster. As for Ethash, which is used in Ethereum, it is two to three times faster.

    Zcoin’s implementation of MPT allows for 4 GB of memory to be used and even then, higher values like Ethash, which is ASIC resistant, refreshes memory every 100 hours¸ while MPT must be refreshed at every block. Using so much memory also has the benefit of being less attractive to botnet mining.

    MPT ASIC is costly to develop as well – especially given the memory usage, limited efficiency gains, and more. As a result, Zcoin’s community may have more time to adopt and grow ASICs before they are viable on the market.

    It is also important to note that a PoW hard fork may not be sustainable. Coins like Monero pursue ASIC resistance in an ad-hoc manner – they schedule hard forks every few months and alter their proof of work algorithm. The theory behind this practice is that the changes limit ASIC lifespan and discourage manufacturers from developing them. There are also some coins that release very little information about any changes, which makes it difficult for ASIC manufacturers from getting ahead.

    There is also growing evidence showing that ASICs may be able to accommodate changes, even with less efficiency. Even with the anti-ASIC approach that many projects take, there are still incentives to not disclose miners to the public. Some even believe that ASICs mined Monero before the public release.

    When a hard fork take place, there is a risk and the introduction of instability into the mining ecosystem. Miners often need to transition to new algorithms and coin security becomes more susceptible to attack. To make matters worse, the POW may be kept secret as well. As a result, new forks take place, which can confuse users. The same issue occurred with Monero 0, Monero V, and Monero Classic.

    Using hard forks just to combat against ASIC resistance may not be sustainable over the long term due to the introduction of risk on the network. For such reasons, it may be better to research and implement algorithms like MPT. Further, dissimilar from other ad-hoc algorithms, MPT has undergone academic review and a funding program by Zcoin to ensure that it is able to overcome cheating and attacks.

    At the end of the day, MTP may be a prime solution for coins like Zcoin, which are still early in distribution stages. Of course, feedback may help the platform improve its MPT, so it is always welcome.

    Get Free Email Updates!

    *Action* Enter Best Email to Get Trending Crypto News & Bitcoin Market Updates

    I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

    Avatar
    Bitcoin Exchange Guide News Team
    B.E.G. Editorial Team is a gracious group of giving cryptocurrency advocates and blockchain believers who want to ensure we do our part in spreading digital currency awareness and adoption. We are a team of over forty individuals all working as a collective whole to produce around the clock daily news, reviews and insights regarding all major coin updates, token announcements and new releases. Make sure to read our editorial policies and follow us on Twitter, Join us in Telegram. Stay tuned. #bitcoin

    [Alert] Use the author's self-conducted information at your own risk, do you own research, never invest more than you are willing to lose.

    [Disclosure] The published news and content on BitcoinExchangeGuide should never be used or taken as financial investment advice. Understand trading cryptocurrencies is a very high-risk activity which can result in significant losses. Editorial Policy \\ Investment Disclaimer

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    3,365FansLike
    2,782FollowersFollow
    4,136FollowersFollow

    Live Bitcoin Price & Latest BTC Charts

    Today's Latest Crypto News

    Cash is King in Coronavirus Ravaged Economy But Bitcoin is “Next in Line to the Throne”: Hedge Fund Manager

    Mark Yusko, the CEO at Morgan Creek Capital Management says coronavirus is unleashing a once in a lifetime downturn. Yusko appeared on CNBC’s “Trading Nation”...

    Bitcoin’s is Gold 2.0; Billionaire Chamath Palihapitiya Lays Out BTC’s Path Forward in Macro Backdrop

    In the latest episode of The Pomp Podcast, host Anthony "Pomp" Pompliano had Chamath Palihapitiya, the CEO of Social Capital as a guest who...

    Binance ‘Leak' Signals Possible Bitcoin Options Trading Launch On The Exchange

    The competition across cryptocurrency exchanges in the crypto derivatives markets is heating up to a boiling point as yet another big player hints at...

    BTC Isn’t a Hedge Against Stock Market’s Poor Returns or Coronavirus But US Dollar & Inflation: BitGo CEO

    In 2020, Bitcoin has been following stock markets religiously, so much so that their correlation went to a new high. But now, the flagship...

    Netflix's ‘Tiger King' Villian, Carole Baskin at The Big Cat Rescue Accepts Crypto Donations

    With the Coronavirus (COVID-19) running rampant in the United States, Americans are drooling over the hot new docuseries on Netflix; “Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem...

    BitcoinExchangeGuide is a hyper-active daily crypto news portal with care in cultivating the cryptocurrency culture with community contributors who help rewrite the bold future of blockchain finance. Subscribe on Google News, see the mission, authors, editorial links policy, investment disclaimer, privacy policy. Got News? Contact us, we are human too. Note: nothing here is financial advice, do your own research thoroughly.