The Word ‘Blockchain’ is a ‘Semantic Wasteland’ that We Should Abandon

Blockchain has gone from a niche tech tool to a household term. You see it on TV commercials for IBM. You see it in discussions on cryptocurrency. Nic Carter of Castle Island Ventures and Coinmetrics.io, however, believes that the word ‘blockchain’ is a “semantic wasteland.” Blockchain is so over-used that it has become meaningless.

In a blog report published earlier today, Carter highlighted a number of issues with the term ‘blockchain’. Because of these issues, Carter believes we should abandon the term.

Nic Carter has a number of serious problems with the term, including the fact that it’s used to refer to a wide range of things from across the industry, including things that aren’t strictly about blockchain:

“…the term persists, an empty semantic husk, kept alive by a thousand press releases, conveying as little meaning as possible. Well past the point of no return, the term is used to refer simultaneously to projects, structures, and databases that have virtually nothing in common. As a consequence, attempts to define it are hopeless, general failures. In this post, I’ll try to explain the origin of ‘blockchain’, and what we should do about it.”

The Origins Of The Term Blockchain

Satoshi Nakamoto created the first popular, widely-used “linked list structure,” explains Carter. However, Satoshi Nakamoto never referred to bitcoin’s system as a blockchain.

Instead, documents like the bitcoin whitepaper refer to bitcoin as a “chain of hash-based proof-of-work” or a “chain of blocks” or a “timechain” (a term not used in the whitepaper but in the original bitcoin codebase).

So no, Satoshi Nakamoto didn’t technically invent the term blockchain, but Satoshi did refer to bitcoin as a “chain of blocks”, so it was easy for users to make the leap to blockchain.

People Who Overuse The Term ‘Blockchain’ Are Masking Their Ignorance

Carter believes that blockchain has become a panacea for all types of innovations in the crypto industry. Platforms are blockchains. Cryptocurrencies are blockchains. Private databases are blockchains.

That’s why he believes that people who overuse blockchain – especially in a general context and without qualifiers – are most likely:

  • Well-meaning people who are forced by convention to use “subpar linguistic tools”
  • People who are a bit muddled, and trying to mask their ignorance with technobabble
  • People who are trying to posture as experts in an industry which realistically has no experts

It’s Wrong To Limit Bitcoin To A Chain Of Blocks

Carter doesn’t just have an issue with the way blockchain is ignorantly used; he also has an issue with the way bitcoin is reduced to a single technological innovation.

If you ask someone what makes bitcoin innovative, they might tell you that it’s the blockchain. This makes it seem like blockchain is the only reason behind bitcoin’s success.

Carter disputes that notion with a clever analogy:

“If I could have you take anything away from this piece, it’s that referring to Bitcoin as a blockchain is like referring to car as a transmission.”

Yes, blockchain is a key element of the system. However, it’s one of several components that make blockchain great:

“Bitcoin relies on a linked list, indeed. But it also relies on a p2p network, an open source and leaderless project, a replicated database, a self-supporting incentive system, a heaviest chain consensus rule, and a proof-of-work (PoW) scheme which gives block proposals unforgeable costliness. (Unforgeable costliness in simple terms: it’s impossible to fake a block submission — you would have to have allocated a good chunk of computing power (energy) to the task. It is therefore hard to create new Bitcoins, but easy for anyone to verify that you worked hard at it.)”

All of these qualities make bitcoin unique, and they’re some of the reasons why bitcoin changed the world after launching in 2009.

“I can’t tell you exactly what the essence of bitcoin is, but to limit it to a chain of blocks is reductionist in the extreme.”

Blockchain is not the soul of bitcoin. It’s just one part of bitcoin that makes it great.

What’s A Better Solution? Which Term Should We Use?

Carter insists that users should be more honest when talking blockchain. Don’t rely on buzzwords to define your product.

“To permissioned/enterprise blockchainers: be honest about what you’re building and in your marketing! If you’re building a database controlled by a consortium of pre-permissioned entities, don’t claim or imply it will have similar reliability characteristics to systems that are designed to live in far more adversarial environments.”

In other words, don’t call your private, permissioned database a blockchain when it’s not.

At the same time, Carter claims that computer scientists should stop mocking non-technical people for using the term ‘blockchain’. Non-technical people might not know the specific meaning behind blockchain. However, the term ‘blockchain’ has come to encompass the whole system – economic and social – rather than just the technical data structure.

Finally, regulators are urged to not define blockchain or create regulations specific to blockchain technology:

“You will fail, not due to your lack of astuteness, but because blockchain is so semantically dispersed as to be un-definable.”

Any regulatory policy will need to be specific enough to be useful, but also general enough to encompass all the different blockchain-like systems. Good luck creating such regulations.

“Please Join Me In Spurning Blockchain At Every Opportunity”

Ultimately, Carter sums up his post with a simple request: that we should stop using the term ‘blockchain’ at every opportunity.

“Let’s try and devise new terms which are specific enough to be useful, and do justice to their referents.”

Carter, for example, refers to permissionless networks like bitcoin as ‘public blockchains’.

What do you think? Should we start phasing out the term ‘blockchain’ to refer to everything in our industry? Or is the term ‘blockchain’ suiting its intended purpose?

Get Free Email Updates!

*Action* Enter Best Email to Get Trending Crypto News & Bitcoin Market Updates

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Avatar
Andrew Tuts
Andrew is a Canadian cryptocurrency analyst who has spent the last seven years writing about digital marketing, science, and technology for hundreds of online publications. Andrew breaks down the latest news from across the crypto and blockchain space in a way anyone – even his parents – can understand.

[Alert] Use the author's self-conducted information at your own risk, do you own research, never invest more than you are willing to lose.

[Disclosure] The published news and content on BitcoinExchangeGuide should never be used or taken as financial investment advice. Understand trading cryptocurrencies is a very high-risk activity which can result in significant losses. Editorial Policy \\ Investment Disclaimer

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

3,511FansLike
2,795FollowersFollow
4,273FollowersFollow

Live Bitcoin Price & Latest BTC Charts

Today's Latest Crypto News

Coinbase and Circle Consortium's USDC Stablecoin is Now Integrated on Solana Blockchain

The Center announced today Solana blockchain as an official Chain for its USDC stablecoin. As an expansion of the “fully-reserved and regulated digital dollar stablecoin,”...

Ethereum Classic & IOHK Team Up to Find Solutions to Prevent 51% Attacks On The Blockchain

The Ethereum Classic Cooperative development team partners with Input Output Hong Kong (IOHK) to counter the numerous 51% attacks on the Ethereum Classic...

OKEx Exchange Resumes P2P Fiat Trading for Chinese Yuan, Indian Rupee, & Vietnamese Dong

Cryptocurrency exchange OKEx announced on Wednesday that it is resuming peer-to-peer (P2P) trading for CNY, INR, and VND fiat pairs from today at 12:00...

SEC Proposes $5 Million Settlement in Kik’s $100 Million Initial Coin Offering (ICO) for KIN

Kik Interactive, the embattled Canadian messaging startup, seems to have finally reached a settlement deal with the SEC regarding its illegal ICO back in...

First UK Public Listed Company, Mode Global Holdings, Converts 10% of Cash Reserves into Bitcoin

What started with public listed company MicroStrategy has now become a movement as more and more companies continue to join the ranks. This month, after...

BitcoinExchangeGuide is a hyper-active daily crypto news portal with care in cultivating the cryptocurrency culture with community contributors who help rewrite the bold future of blockchain finance. Subscribe on Google News, see the mission, authors, editorial links policy, investment disclaimer, privacy policy. Got News? Contact us, we are human too. Note: nothing here is financial advice, do your own research thoroughly.

Start Using Crypto Today