US Court Tosses Appeal in Child Exploitation Case; Accessing Coinbase Account Didn't Violate Fourth Amendment Rights

Both Gratkowski and Ross Ulbricht are among those who sought to appeal on violation of the Fourth Amendment.

Richard Gratkowski, convicted of purchasing and receiving child pornography, and accessing websites with an intent to access child porn, was sentenced to 70 months in prison and ten years of probation.

He has appealed against the FBI for accessing his Coinbase transaction history record, suggesting it violates his fourth amendment rights, which protects people from unreasonable searches and seizures by the government.

A three-judge panel, which oversaw the case, ruled against the convict's appeal and said that FBI accessing his Coinbase record to confirm he used bitcoin to buy child porn does not violate his fourth amendment right.

The court has likened Coinbase to a traditional bank in their verdict on the matter and referred to the unanimous 1939 decision in the United States v. Miller case, which ruled bank records are not protected under the fourth amendment.

Judge Catharina Haynes, who was overseeing the case, noted that the only difference between Coinbase and a traditional bank is that Coinbase offers services for virtual currencies while traditional bank deals with fiat. She said:

“Coinbase is a financial institution, a virtual currency exchange that provides Bitcoin users with a method for transferring Bitcoin. The main difference between Coinbase and traditional banks, which were at issue in Miller, is that Coinbase deals with virtual currency while traditional banks deal with physical currency.”

The FBI, in their investigation in the child pornography case, found that the convicted Gratkowski used bitcoin to pay for child pornography between 2016 and 2017. When the federal agents analyzed the transaction data, it was associated with a wallet linked to Coinbase. The agents later searched Gratkowski's home and found a hard drive containing child pornography.

Silk Road Ross Ulbricht's Appeal Was Rejected

Gratkowski appealed against his conviction and said that his bitcoin records should be subjected to the same set of jurisdiction as it was shown with cell-site location information in the Supreme Court's 2018 Carpenter v. United States decision.

However, the judging panel disagreed with Gratkowski. Arguing that his case couldn't be seen in the same light as cell-site location, as his bitcoin transaction history did not invade his privacy, or give away aspects of his life that he had the right to keep private. The judge said,

“The nature of the information on the Bitcoin blockchain and the voluntariness of the exposure weigh heavily against finding a privacy interest in an individual's information on the Bitcoin blockchain.”

Gratkowski is not the first person to use the fourth amendment argument to protect their privacy. Before him, Silk Road founder – Ross Ulbricht – during his trial, also claimed that his prosecution violated his Fourth Amendment rights in its use of data in identifying him.

Get Free Email Updates!

*Action* Enter Best Email to Get Trending Crypto News & Bitcoin Market Updates

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Hank Klinger
Hank Klinger
Hank Klinger has been working online for seven years now. He has written for several national companies. Hank has been a part of our team for over three years, reviewing ICOs, new cryptocurrencies and helping us keep up to date with industry news. His primary knowledge is in marketing, sales, and advertising, and he uses that knowledge to research and pick out reliable sources of information to use as a basis for his writing.

[Alert] Use the author's self-conducted information at your own risk, do you own research, never invest more than you are willing to lose.

[Disclosure] The published news and content on BitcoinExchangeGuide should never be used or taken as financial investment advice. Understand trading cryptocurrencies is a very high-risk activity which can result in significant losses. Editorial Policy \\ Investment Disclaimer


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Live Bitcoin Price & Latest BTC Charts

Today's Latest Crypto News

Second Half of 3-Yr Bull Market: Ether’s Crazy Run has 90% of its Supply in Profit

This past weekend, the price of Ether went past $400 to as high as about $420, a level last seen in July 2018. This...

Teenage Mastermind Behind the Twitter Hack Owns $3.39 Million in Bitcoin (300 BTC); Bail Set At $725k

The 17-year old Twitter-hack mastermind holds over $3 million in BTC value with only $725,000 set for bail. In a bizarre moment last month, Twitter...

Bitcoin (BTC) Jumped to $100,000 on Binance Futures

There have been several predictions that see Bitcoin hitting a six-digit figure. On Sunday, this became a reality, very briefly, thanks to an algorithm. Bitcoin...

Flash Crash Caused Serious Network Congestion for ETH, ETC, And ERC 20 Tokens on Coinbase

On August 1, the Ethereum's blockchain faced a spike in network transaction fees, causing a backlog in transfers across several exchanges. Coinbase and Binance,...

Bitcoin’s Wild Weekend Reminiscent of 2017 Bull Rally, ‘Higher Highs Ahead in 2020'

This past weekend, bitcoin had a rough time as the largest cryptocurrency made its way past $12,000 to $12,112 in trading just after midnight...

BitcoinExchangeGuide is a hyper-active daily crypto news portal with care in cultivating the cryptocurrency culture with community contributors who help rewrite the bold future of blockchain finance. Subscribe on Google News, see the mission, authors, editorial links policy, investment disclaimer, privacy policy. Got News? Contact us, we are human too. Note: nothing here is financial advice, do your own research thoroughly.

Start Using Crypto Today